Series Review: His Dark Materials, Season One (HBO)
A young girl is destined to liberate her world from the grip of the Magisterium which represses people’s ties to magic and their animal spirits known as daemons.
Though interesting on first glance, the characters in this show fall flat to me in the long run. They don’t measure up to the movie version or the books by a long shot.
While the plot started off well enough, it ended up becoming a quickly sinking ship that didn’t seem to have a real rhyme or reason.
The flow was good in the beginning, but later on the number of subplots alone seems to ruin any kind of flow.
I really wanted to like this, but it is awful in the long run (I have NO idea why it’s receiving such acclaim). Characters vividly portrayed in the book and movie version (yes, I’m comparing, and you should too!) with intriguing personalities and wonderful speeches are painted in a bland sense. The speeches didn’t feel inspired enough to excite me.
And the plot? Jesus. BBC clearly tried to overcomplicate the plot in this first season, which ended up confusing and frankly, disappointing. Also, large parts of the plot in the Earthlike world simply could’ve been cut out. It had very little entertainment value. Did BBC skimp on visual effects, or is it just me?
If you can get over the odd pacing, plot holes, and overcomplication, sure, try this out. But I can not recommend it. I will not be watching the second season of this travesty.
That’s it for this series review. How about you? Have you seen this one?
Did you enjoy it? Love it, hate it? Feel free to comment, and have a great day!
***Can’t get enough of Jaunts & Haunts? Subscribe to my Chills and Thrills Newsletter on my home page so you don’t miss a thing! Newsletter emails go out every Sunday! Also, feel free to check me out at the social media links below!***
Oh dear. Well, it sounds like I should skip this one!
I will admit that I’m biased based on my reading the books and seeing the movie prior, but my friends who hadn’t read the books didn’t like it much either. By the end, we were hate-watching it just to finish the season lol.
Thanks for the heads up. I’ll avoid this.
They did certainly try to make something out of this, but after the first couple of episodes it just got really tedious and uninspired.
I find that with a lot of series. The first few episodes are interesting and then it falls apart.
Yeah, its unfortunate. I loved the series of books so it was heartbreaking that they messed it up so bad.